701 N 44th St, Phoenix, AZ 85008
480.429.3000

Beus Gilbert McGroder

  • Practice Areas
    • Plaintiffs Commercial Litigation
    • Zoning & Real Estate
    • Plaintiffs Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Our Firm
  • Our Team
  • News
  • Contact

701 N 44th St, Phoenix, AZ 85008

480.429.3000

Beus Gilbert McGroder

  • Practice Areas
    • Plaintiffs Commercial Litigation
    • Zoning & Real Estate
    • Plaintiffs Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Our Firm
  • Our Team
  • News
  • Contact
  • Practice Areas
    • Plaintiffs Commercial Litigation
    • Zoning & Real Estate
    • Plaintiffs Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death
  • Our Firm
  • Our Team
  • News
  • Contact
by Gay Mennuti
CommentaryMay 20, 19920 comments

Accountant Hit With Judgment of $338 Million

By The Associated Press, Los Angeles Times  Published:  May 20, 1992

An Arizona Jury Says a Price Waterhouse Audit Led to a British Firm Making a Losing Investment in a Bank

PHOENIX — A state jury on Tuesday told Price Waterhouse to pay $338 million to a British banking firm because the accounting firm’s audit led to a losing investment in an Arizona bank.

The jury agreed with London-based Standard Chartered that Price Waterhouse bungled its audit of United Bank in 1985 and 1986. The British company had alleged in a Maricopa County Superior Court lawsuit that Price Waterhouse failed to alert the firm to bad loans on the bank’s books and grossly overstated its financial condition.

New York-based Price Waterhouse is one of the nation’s largest accounting firms.

Standard Chartered bought United Bank in January 1987, for about $335 million and sold it 16 months later to Citicorp for about $208 million–a $127 million loss.

The eight-person jury found that Price Waterhouse engaged in negligent misrepresentation and breach of fiduciary duty in working for Standard Chartered.

The jury decided to award the banking company roughly the amount it paid for United Bank.

Erica B. Baird, a spokeswoman for Price Waterhouse in New York, said the firm was outraged at the verdict and will appeal directly to the judge to dismiss the award.

She said the firm has a contingency plan to limit the effect of the award.

“We have insurance, and service to clients won’t be interrupted,” she said. “We are confident we can get the judgment stayed pending the appeal.”

She said the firm was relieved that the jury didn’t find that it had violated the Arizona Civil Racketeering Act, which would have allowed the damages to be tripled to more than $1 billion.

Leo Beus, attorney for Standard Chartered, said he was pleased with the verdict despite failing to get triple damages.

“This sends a signal not to trust auditors,” Beus said. “The jury wanted very badly to decide for Price Waterhouse, but they just couldn’t. The jury was very patient.”

The trial, which began in June of last year, was the longest civil trial in the state’s history, court officials said.

Beus said it was Arizona’s biggest civil award ever. Mary Budinger, a spokeswoman for Maricopa County Superior Court, said the court doesn’t keep such records.

Baird, Price Waterhouse’s spokeswoman, said that the auditing firm was being made a scapegoat for a bad business decision by Standard Chartered and that the trial was bent in favor of the plaintiffs.

“This is an 11-month trial,” she said. “In the 11 months, Price Waterhouse was given 25 days to present its case.”

Read Article

A $128.1 Million Settlement Reached In Miniscribe CaseNext

Latest Posts

by Gay Mennuti

In Loving Memory

It is with profound sorrow that we announce the passing of Leo R. Beus.Leo was our beloved friend, partner, teacher and mentor. He has guided the firm...

In Loving Memory

Leo Beus, NewsNovember 18, 2022
by Gay Mennuti

Beus Gilbert McGroder Named In “Best Law Firms” (2023 Edition)

Beus Gilbert McGroder Phoenix lawyers recognized in Best Lawyers in America® (2023 Edition)Leo R. Beus - Recognized in Best Lawyers since...

Beus Gilbert McGroder Named In “Best Law Firms” (2023 Edition)

Press ReleaseNovember 8, 2022
by Gay Mennuti

Patrick J. McGroder Named Top Trial Lawyer 2022 by Phoenix Magazine

Patrick J. McGroder III has contributed $50,000 to the University of Arizona Law's Advocacy program.

Patrick J. McGroder Named Top Trial Lawyer 2022 by Phoenix Magazine

NewsSeptember 22, 2022

Beus
Gilbert
McGroder PLLC

Practice Areas

Plaintiffs Commercial Litigation

Zoning & Real Estate

Plaintiffs Catastrophic Injury & Wrongful Death

About Us

Firm

Attorneys

Professionals

News

Contact

Office

701 North 44th Street
Phoenix, AZ 85008

Email: info@beusgilbert.com

Phone: 480.429.3000

Fax: 480.429.3100

Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2019-2023 Beus Gilbert McGroder PLLC. All rights reserved.

Website Maintenance proudly provided by Mackmedia.

Website by Kitchen Sink Studios.